In short: the US (CAN-SPAM) is opt-out: you can email people without asking first, as long as the email is honest, carries a postal address and lets them stop. Canada (CASL) is opt-in: you need consent before you send, implied consent expires (2 years after a purchase, 6 months after an inquiry), and you must be able to prove it. CASL covers messages sent to or opened on computers in Canada, so a US company emailing Canadians must follow it. If you email both countries, the simplest approach is to build every email to CASL's stricter rules and manage consent separately for Canadian subscribers.
Most US brands find Canada through growth: Canadian customers start buying, then sign up, then end up on the same list as everyone else. Here's what changes when they do.
CASL and CAN-SPAM side by side
| United States (CAN-SPAM) | Canada (CASL) | |
|---|---|---|
| Model | Opt-out: no consent needed before you send | Opt-in: consent needed before you send |
| Who it covers | Commercial email | Commercial messages sent to or accessed from computers in Canada, wherever the sender is |
| Consent | Not required | Express (lasts until withdrawn) or implied (mainly an existing business relationship, and time-limited) |
| How long implied consent lasts | Not applicable | 2 years from a purchase, lease or end of a contract; 6 months from an inquiry or application |
| Proof | No consent to prove | You must be able to prove consent if asked |
| Who sent it | Honest From, Reply-To and routing details | Name the sender and anyone it's sent on behalf of |
| Address and contact | A valid physical postal address | A mailing address plus a phone number, email address or web address, valid for 60 days |
| "This is an ad" | Must say it's an advertisement, unless the person gave prior affirmative consent | No separate ad label, but the message mustn't mislead |
| Unsubscribe | Clear and conspicuous; works for at least 30 days | Clear and prominent; works for at least 60 days |
| Acting on opt-outs | Within 10 business days | Within 10 business days |
| Subject lines | Mustn't mislead about the content | Mustn't mislead (Competition Act) |
| Transactional email | Exempt from most rules, but routing details must be honest | Quotes, confirmations, warranty and account notices don't need consent, but still need sender details and an unsubscribe |
| Penalties | Up to $53,088 for each email that breaks the law | Up to C$10 million per violation for a business, C$1 million for an individual |
| Regulator | Federal Trade Commission (FTC) | CRTC; the Competition Bureau for misleading sender and subject details |
The big difference: consent
Under CAN-SPAM you can add a customer to your marketing list without asking, as long as you honour their opt-out. Under CASL that same customer is covered only by implied consent, and only for a while:
- Bought something? Implied consent for 2 years from the purchase.
- Asked a question or made an application? 6 months from the inquiry.
- Ticked a clear "yes, email me"? That's express consent, and it lasts until they withdraw it.
So a Canadian customer who bought once in 2024 and hasn't bought since can't be emailed in 2027 unless they gave express consent. That's the rule most US programmes break without realising: the list grows, and nobody tracks when implied consent ran out.
When you ask for express consent, CASL also wants the request to say why you're asking, who is asking (and for whom, if you're an agency), give your contact details, and say the person can withdraw at any time.
What to change if you already email Canadians
- Know who's in Canada. Ask for country at sign-up and checkout, and keep it on the profile. You can't apply Canadian rules to people you can't find.
- Ask for express consent. Add a clear, unticked "email me" option at sign-up and checkout for Canadian customers, worded as above.
- Track the clock on implied consent. Store the date of each Canadian customer's last purchase or inquiry, and stop marketing to them when the window closes, unless they've given express consent.
- Run a re-permission campaign before implied consent runs out: one or two emails asking them to opt in, then stop.
- Upgrade the footer. Name the sender (and the client, if you're an agency), give a mailing address and one more contact route, and keep them all working for 60 days after each send.
- Keep unsubscribes working for 60 days, not 30, and sync opt-outs to every list and tool well inside 10 business days.
- Keep records of when and how each person agreed. If the CRTC asks, the burden is on you.
One email for both countries
You don't need two separate programmes. Build every email to the stricter of the two rules and you're covered in both:
- A footer with the sender's name, postal address and another contact route (CASL's requirement covers CAN-SPAM's).
- An unsubscribe link that's easy to find, works in one step and keeps working for 60 days.
- Honest from names and subject lines.
- Consent managed by country: US subscribers on opt-out rules, Canadian subscribers only with valid express or implied consent.
Emailing customers in Quebec adds a language question too: see French-language email marketing in Quebec.
Questions
Does CASL apply to US companies?
Yes. CASL covers commercial messages sent to or accessed from computers in Canada, wherever the sender is based. A US company emailing Canadian subscribers must follow it.
What is the main difference between CASL and CAN-SPAM?
Consent. CAN-SPAM is opt-out: you can email people without asking first, as long as you let them stop. CASL is opt-in: you need express or implied consent before you send, and implied consent expires.
How long does implied consent last under CASL?
Two years from a purchase, lease or the end of a contract, and six months from an inquiry or application. Express consent lasts until the person withdraws it.
How fast must you process unsubscribes in the US and Canada?
Within 10 business days in both countries. The unsubscribe link must keep working for at least 30 days after the email is sent in the US, and at least 60 days in Canada.
What are the penalties under CASL and CAN-SPAM?
Under CASL, up to C$10 million per violation for a business and C$1 million for an individual. Under CAN-SPAM, up to $53,088 for each email that breaks the law, according to the FTC.
Sources
- Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation, S.C. 2010, c. 23, sections 1 to 9 and sections 10 to 13 (Justice Laws Website, Government of Canada)
- Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations (CRTC), SOR/2012-36
- Frequently Asked Questions about Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CRTC)
- Getting consent to send email (Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada)
- CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business (Federal Trade Commission)
- 15 U.S. Code § 7704 and 16 CFR § 316.5 (Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School)
*Checked on 9 November 2026 against the sources above and Mailfois's own Canada and US rules cards.*