Mailfois
Guides / Email approval matrix
Guide

Email approval matrix: who signs off which marketing emails (free template)

An email approval matrix sets out who signs off each kind of marketing email, who only checks one part and who is just told. Here's how to build one, an example, and a free template to download.

In short: an email approval matrix is a table. Down the side, the kinds of email you send (newsletter, sale, prize draw, launch, automated email). Across the top, the people who might approve them (campaign owner, brand, legal, pricing, market reviewers, the client). Each cell says whether that person signs off the email, checks one part of it, is told when it's done, or isn't involved. Add a reply time for each person, and one name who has the final say. Download the free template (CSV, opens in Excel or Google Sheets).

Without a matrix, approvals drift to one of two extremes. Either everyone reviews everything, and every email waits for the slowest person, or nobody is sure who should have looked, and the mistake is found after the send. A matrix fixes both in one page.

The four answers

Keep it to four, so anyone can read the matrix at a glance:

  • Signs off: must approve the whole email before it can go. Keep this to as few people as possible, ideally one per email.
  • Checks a part: approves only their part (the offer, the terms line, the footer, the German version) and nothing else.
  • Told: sees it once it's approved, with no say. Useful for stakeholders who want to know what's going out.
  • Not involved: left blank.

If you know RACI, this is the same idea in plainer words: "signs off" is accountable, "checks a part" is consulted, "told" is informed.

An example

For an in-house team sending to the UK, Ireland and Germany:

Kind of emailCampaign ownerBrandLegalPricingMarket reviewerHead of CRM
NewsletterSigns offChecks a part (language)Told
Sale or promotionSigns offChecks a part (price claims)Checks a part (prices and codes)Checks a part (language)Told
Prize drawSigns offChecks a part (terms)Checks a part (language)Told
New product launchSigns offChecks a part (look and claims)Checks a part (if claims)Checks a part (prices)Checks a part (language)Told
Automated email (new or changed)Signs offChecks a part (look)Checks a part (footer and consent)Checks a part (language)Told
New footer or consent wordingSigns offChecks a part (language)Told
Reply time1 day2 days2 days1 day2 days

Notice what isn't there: brand doesn't review every newsletter, legal doesn't review emails without claims, and the head of CRM is told rather than asked. Each "checks a part" names the part.

How to build yours in five steps

  1. List the kinds of email you actually send. Six to ten rows is enough. Group anything that's checked the same way.
  2. List everyone who currently reviews anything. Then ask of each: what are they really checking for? That's their part.
  3. Fill in the cells, starting from "not involved". Add a role only where there's a real risk they're there to catch. Most cells should end up blank or "told".
  4. Name one final approver per row. Two people who can both say no, with no tie-breaker, is how emails get stuck.
  5. Add reply times and cover. How long each person has, and who covers when they're away. Then share it with everyone in the matrix and agree it.

Rules that keep it working

  • Approve parts, not whole emails. Legal approves the terms line; they don't need to comment on the hero image.
  • Approved stays approved. If the next version doesn't change someone's part, their approval should carry over, and only changed parts go back.
  • Approved wording doesn't need approving again. A footer or consent line legal approved last month, used word for word, is already approved.
  • Reply-by dates, with reminders. A reply time only works if someone is reminded the day before it's due.
  • Cover for absences. Every approver has a named cover, so a holiday doesn't stop the send.
  • Review the matrix twice a year, or whenever a new kind of email or a new market starts.

For agencies

Add the client as a column, and usually as the final approver. Most agencies also add a stage before the client sees anything: the agency's own team approves first, then the client gets the email. Agree how many rounds of changes are included, and put that and the client's reply time in the matrix too, so extra rounds are a conversation rather than a surprise (more in how many revision rounds to include). See client approval for agencies.

The free template

Download the email approval matrix template. It has the example above, a key and blank rows to adapt. It opens in Excel, Numbers and Google Sheets (File, Import).

For who should check what in legal review specifically, see how to get marketing emails approved by legal, and for what each approver should look for, the email sign-off checklist.

Questions

What is an email approval matrix?

A table that sets out, for each kind of marketing email, who must sign it off, who checks only one part of it, who is told when it's done, and how long each person has to reply.

Who should sign off marketing emails?

One person per email, usually the campaign owner (or the client, for an agency). Others such as legal, pricing and market reviewers check only their part. More than one final approver is the most common reason emails get stuck.

Is an approval matrix the same as RACI?

It's the same idea in plainer words. "Signs off" is accountable, "checks a part" is consulted and "told" is informed. Most email teams don't need a separate "responsible" column, because the builder is always responsible.

How often should you update the approval matrix?

Twice a year, and whenever you start a new kind of email, enter a new market or someone in the matrix changes role.

Written by Mailfois. Mailfois is built by someone who works in email marketing and also builds apps. About Mailfois.

Run your approval matrix without chasing anyone.

Try Mailfois free